Sonora Union High School District | Facial recognition cameras
In August 2024 the district superintendent told a school safety meeting that the district had eight new cameras with facial recognition. Our research found no other documented facial recognition in the county, and no records about these cameras beyond that statement.
At a glance
- Devices
- 8 cameras, described as having facial recognition [1]
- Source of that figure
- the district superintendent, at a school safety meeting [1]
- Vendor
- not named in the record we found [1]
- Facial recognition in use
- the record describes the capability, not whether it is switched on [1]
- Board approval
- no district board item found; the district publishes agendas on a portal we could not search [2]
- Governing policy
- none found [2]
How it happened
- Deployment
The superintendent describes eight cameras with facial recognition
Notes from a school safety planning meeting, printed in a Sonora City Council packet, record superintendent Ed Pelfrey saying: "We're trying to increase the ability of our camera system; we have 8 new cameras with facial recognition." The Sonora police chief attended the same meeting. [1]
- Context
The district's board records are not searchable from the open web
The district posts board agendas through a portal that does not expose the documents' text to search engines or to automated retrieval, so the agendas cannot be keyword-searched from outside. We found no board item covering the purchase. Seven of the eight school boards whose platforms we checked publish through the same system. [2] [3]
On 5 August 2024 the Sonora City Council’s meeting packet included notes from a school safety planning meeting. Among those present were the city’s police chief and Ed Pelfrey, the superintendent of Sonora Union High School District. The notes record, under the superintendent’s name: “We’re trying to increase the ability of our camera system; we have 8 new cameras with facial recognition.”[1]
Our research found no other documented facial recognition in Tuolumne County. The note does not name the vendor, say whether the capability is switched on, or describe what happens to the images, how long they are held, or who can search them.
We went looking for a school board record of the purchase. The district publishes its agendas through a portal that does not expose their text to search engines or to automated retrieval, so its board records cannot be keyword-searched from outside. We found no board item covering the cameras.[2][3] Seven of the eight school boards whose meeting platforms we checked publish through the same system, so the same limit applies to most school governance here.
This entry is marked as reported rather than verified for that reason. The claim comes from an official speaking in a public setting, recorded in a public document, and we have not been able to confirm or extend it from the district’s own records. A public records request to the district is the next step.
Questions
- Does a school in Tuolumne County use facial recognition?
- The superintendent of Sonora Union High School District said in August 2024 that the district had eight new cameras with facial recognition. We could not find a record showing whether the facial recognition capability is switched on, what system the cameras run, or how any data is handled. [1]
- What else does the public record say about these cameras?
- Very little that we could find. The description we located is a single sentence in notes from a stakeholder meeting. We found no vendor name, no board approval, no policy, and no statement about retention or access. [1] [2]
- Why does a city council packet contain school district information?
- The notes come from a school safety meeting attended by city and school officials, and they were included in the Sonora City Council's packet for its meeting of 5 August 2024. [1]
What we do not know
- What system are the cameras running, and is the facial recognition capability enabled?
- Did the district's governing board approve the purchase, and at which meeting?
- What policy governs the cameras, and are students and families notified?
- How long is footage kept, who can access it, and is it shared with law enforcement?
What you can do
Show up
Systems like this one are approved by boards, councils and committees that meet in public. We have confirmed where each of them meets in Tuolumne County and how public comment works there.
How to show up in Tuolumne County →Protect yourself
Practical steps to shrink your personal data trail. Our guides publish at launch; until then, EFF's Surveillance Self-Defense is the best starting point.
Surveillance Self-Defense →Sources
- 1. City of Sonora council packet of August 5, 2024, school safety stakeholder meeting notes · Meeting record · · accessed · archived copy
- 2. Sonora Union High School District board meeting listing · Meeting record · accessed · archived copy
- 3. Sonora Union High School District, board agendas page · Primary document · accessed · archived copy
Get the digest
A regular digest of what changed in the world of surveillance: the counties we published, the devices that appeared on the map, and the public meetings where these decisions get made. We send it when there is enough to report.
One click to unsubscribe. What we do with your address is on the newsletter page.