Bannock County Sheriff | Security cameras at five county buildings
In 2024 the Board of County Commissioners put security cameras for five county sites out to competitive bid, split the award between two companies, and signed contracts worth $219,499. It is the one camera purchase in this county that went to open bidding.
At a glance
- Approved
- Bids opened 30 July 2024, awards recommended and approved 13 August 2024, contracts signed 3 September 2024 [1] [2] [3]
- Price
- $52,560.56 to ProEdge Technology and $166,939 to Summit Communications [3]
- How it was bought
- An Invitation to Bid. The county split the solicitation by location rather than asking for one total price, which its procurement officer told the Board was to allow better competition [1]
- Where the cameras go
- Five county sites. The Courthouse and the Detention Center to ProEdge Technology; Public Works, the Wellness Complex and Event Center, and the Fairgrounds in Downey to Summit Communications [2]
- A written policy
- None is published on the county website, and none is named in the commissioners' record we read [4]
How it happened
- Procurement
The bids are opened
The Board opens the sealed bids for the security camera Invitation to Bid. The county's chief procurement officer explains that the solicitation originally asked for one total cost and was changed to list each location separately, to allow better competition. [1]
- Decision
The award is split between two companies
The procurement officer recommends awarding the Courthouse and the Detention Center to ProEdge Technology, and Public Works, the Wellness Complex and Event Center, and the Fairgrounds in Downey to Summit Communications. One bidder had been disqualified for not including labor. The Board approves the awards. [2]
- Procurement
The contracts are signed
The Board approves the contract with ProEdge Technology for $52,560.56 and the contract with Summit Communications for $166,939. [3]
This one is here for contrast as much as for content.
Cameras at the courthouse, bought in the open
In the summer of 2024 the county needed security cameras for five of its buildings. It put the work out to an Invitation to Bid, and when the first version of the solicitation asked bidders for a single total price, the county’s procurement officer changed it to price each location separately. Her stated reason, in the minutes, was to allow better competition.
The bids were opened at a public meeting on 30 July. One bidder was disqualified for leaving labor out. Two weeks later the Board split the award: the Courthouse and the Detention Center to ProEdge Technology, and Public Works, the Wellness Complex and Event Center, and the Fairgrounds in Downey to Summit Communications. The contracts were signed on 3 September for $52,560.56 and $166,939.
These are building security cameras on county property, which is a different thing from a camera network on public roads. They watch the entrances to a courthouse and a jail, not everyone who drives past them.
Why it matters that this one was bid
A year later the same Board approved plate readers for the Sheriff’s Office with no bidding process in the record, and the City Council down the road had already approved 34 plate readers as a declared sole source purchase. The county knows how to run a competition for a camera contract. It ran one here, for the cheaper and less intrusive system, and the record we read does not show one for either plate reader purchase.
What is not in the record
The minutes record the award and the amounts. They do not say how many cameras went in at each site, what they cover, how long the footage is kept or who may look at it. The bid specification inside the county’s own meeting packet names acceptable manufacturers for the video management system and the recorders; it does not say which was chosen.
What we do not know
- How many cameras were installed at each site, and what do they cover?
- How long is the footage kept, and who may view it?
- The bid specification in the county's own packet lists acceptable manufacturers for the video management system and the recorders. Which was installed?
What you can do
Show up
Systems like this one are approved by boards, councils and committees that meet in public. We have confirmed where each of them meets in Bannock County and how public comment works there.
How to show up in Bannock County →Protect yourself
Practical steps to shrink your personal data trail. Our guides publish at launch; until then, EFF's Surveillance Self-Defense is the best starting point.
Surveillance Self-Defense →Sources
- 1. Bannock County Board of County Commissioners minutes, 30 July 2024 · Meeting record · · accessed
- 2. Bannock County Board of County Commissioners minutes, 13 August 2024 · Meeting record · · accessed
- 3. Bannock County Board of County Commissioners minutes, 3 September 2024 · Meeting record · · accessed
- 4. Bannock County website, Commissioners and Sheriff pages · Primary document · accessed
Get the digest
A regular digest of what changed in the world of surveillance: the counties we published, the devices that appeared on the map, and the public meetings where these decisions get made. We send it when there is enough to report.
One click to unsubscribe. What we do with your address is on the newsletter page.